Offbeat Veterans Go Back to Court Over Burn Pits. Do They Have a Chance?

15:47  17 may  2018
15:47  17 may  2018 Source:   nytimes.com

Veterans ask court to reinstate lawsuits over open burn pits

  Veterans ask court to reinstate lawsuits over open burn pits Veterans and their families have asked a federal appeals court to reinstate lawsuits against a government contractor who they claim caused health problems by using burn pits in Iraq and Afghanistan. Last year, a judge in Maryland dismissed lawsuits against KBR, a former Halliburton subsidiary. The judge found that analyzing military decision-making during war is a political question not appropriate for judicial review.

A soldier pushing a bulldozer deep into the flames of a burn pit at Balad, Iraq, in September 2004, to keep burnable items constantly ablaze.CreditU.S. Army photo.

The Veteran Affairs Medical Centers have created a “ burn pit registry,” which the Casper veterans are a part of. Going after KBR is a bit low. Halliburton/KBR were hit with pretty big asbestos lawsuits a while back .

a person standing on top of a dirt field: American soldiers burning garbage at a combat outpost outside Baghdad in December 2007. © Marko Drobnjakovic/Associated Press American soldiers burning garbage at a combat outpost outside Baghdad in December 2007.

On May 9, a federal appeals court heard oral arguments in a case about an explosive issue among U.S. veterans: the widespread use of burn pits in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the potential health consequences they suffered as a result.

Sign Up For the Morning Briefing Newsletter 

The case, which dates back to 2008, consolidated dozens of lawsuits by hundreds of veterans and their families seeking to recover damages from the military contractor KBR Inc., but a trial court dismissed it in July 2017. It could be at a legal dead end unless the panel of judges, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Va., overturns the dismissal.

AP Source: Trump considering Army veteran for VA secretary

  AP Source: Trump considering Army veteran for VA secretary President Donald Trump is considering an Army veteran who is a Republican member of Congress for the position of Veterans Affairs secretary. It's part of a lengthening search for a nominee following the abrupt firing of David Shulkin in March.A White House official says Rep. Brian Mast of Florida is among the list of candidates for the job serving 9 million veterans.Mast is the first member of Congress to open a lawmaker office in a VA facility, setting up shop in the West Palm Beach VA to meet with veterans. He was wounded when serving in Afghanistan in 2010, which resulted in the amputation of both of his legs.

RELATED: Court Deals Major Blow To Veterans Suiting Over Burn Pits . Genius H Kennard August 9, 2017 at 7:43 pm. They should have been shipped back over seas immediately! I believe those stupid lawyers & the judge are marked that’s not patriotic whatsoever.

Tortured Islamic Terrorists Get Day In Court , Iraq Burn Pit Veterans Get Denied. NP’s were working at kaiser back in the early 90’s and this has permeated all over the private health care system here in the U.S. I often said, that pretty soon a janitor would be able to do surgery and we’re not far from that

The plaintiffs accuse KBR of negligence for exposing them to toxic emissions from open-air trash fires known as burn pits, which they say cause respiratory, neurological and other health problems. In tossing the case last year, the trial court accepted KBR’s argument that the American military made the decision to use burn pits to dispose of trash on bases, and that federal courts cannot second-guess the executive branch’s wartime decisions.

One plaintiff, Lauren Price, a Navy veteran from Pasco County, Fla., who developed constrictive bronchiolitis after working at a burn pit in Baghdad, said in an interview that she has already given up hope. “I’ve stopped paying attention,” she said. After 10 years of litigation, the case is still at the procedural starting gates, and unless the plaintiffs eke out a win on appeal, it will be one of the biggest setbacks yet for tens of thousands of affected veterans who have received zero recompense despite years of advocacy by lawyers and nonprofits.

World War II vet, 99, on mission to meet every state's governor

  World War II vet, 99, on mission to meet every state's governor Sidney Walton, a 99-year-old World War II veteran, is on a new mission — and he’s about to bring it to New York. Walton, a Brooklyn native who lives in San Diego, is traveling the nation with the goal of meeting every governor by the time he turns 100 in February. He hopes to shake hands with Gov. Cuomo sometime this week.Walton hopes the “No Regrets Tour” will raise awareness to the fact that World War II veterans are rapidly dying off. He wants to give as many people as possible the chance to meet him and talk with a survivor of the war.

Home › Main Forums › General Discussion › Federal Court Dismisses US Veterans ’ Lawsuit Over The long, sad story of burn pits has included years of US veterans facing major health …and you think you’re going to stop this simply by ‘pulling a lever’, in a booth, behind a curtain, every 2 years?

That’s not the case, however, as US District Court Judge Roger Titus has dismissed a lawsuit by veterans and family members related to the health problems, and even deaths, caused by the burn pits , saying there was no way to hold anyone accountable for it.

The controversy is at a point where it could become the subject of a Supreme Court decision or an act of Congress. Here’s a brief introduction to an issue that has risen over time from the lowest military scuttlebutt to the highest levels of American government.

What is a burn pit?

The military bases the United States maintained for eight years in Iraq and 17 years to date in Afghanistan were hardly spartan encampments. There were air-conditioned stores, fast-food restaurants, movie theaters, internet cafes and swimming pools. Soldiers bunked in prefabricated trailers and dined in spacious chow halls serving up hot square meals three times a day. All that consumption produced garbage, lots of it, which had to somehow be disposed of. The solution? Dump it into open-air pits, drench it in jet fuel and light it on fire.

On the largest American bases, like Camp Victory in Baghdad or Camp Anaconda near Balad, a perpetual miasma lingered over the tents and trailers, reeking of burnt plastic. The effect, worsened by the extreme heat, could be nauseating. Until 2010, when the Department of Defense banned burn pits, soldiers complained of coughing up “black gunk.” Thousands came home from deployment with some kind of respiratory illness, mostly mild or moderate, but including career-ending lung diseases and fatal cancers. Former Vice President Joe Biden has even speculated that his son died from burn-pit exposure; Beau Biden received a rare brain-cancer diagnosis in 2013 at the age of 44, four years after a deployment to Iraq.

House votes to expand veterans' access to private care

  House votes to expand veterans' access to private care House lawmakers on Wednesday overwhelmingly passed legislation expanding veterans' access to private care at taxpayer expense, a campaign promise of President Donald Trump, and adding more money to the "Choice program" weeks before VA officials said it could run out of money. The $51 billion plan that passed 347-70 Wednesday includes $5.2 billion for the VA Choice program that funds private care. VA officials have warned that the program could run out of money as early as the end of the month, disrupting care for patients. Hours before the House vote, Trump weighed in, urging lawmakers to back the bill.

Tortured Islamic Terrorists Get Day In Court , Iraq Burn Pit Veterans Get Denied. Once that munition goes over seas, those plans go out the window. I understand the exigencies of battle, but what urgent threat is there preventing proper disposal of trash?

The open air burn pits did not effectively burn the volume of waste generated which created a vast Bottom line is that we all went over there after passing several physicals and came back with all Last week (April 14 2011) my Doctor finally had a chance to review my biopsy performed while I was still

In 2013, in response to rising concerns from doctors and veterans’ advocates, Congress directed the V.A. to set up a registry of veterans who were exposed to burn pits. More than 142,000 have signed up so far.

So burn pits cause lung disease?

Deployments are associated with an increased risk of asthma and emphysema as well as a number of rare respiratory conditions, but there are numerous factors that could contribute to these illnesses.. Iraq and Afghanistan are two of the world’s most polluted countries, and there are also dust storms, oil-well fires and battlefield explosions to take into account, not to mention the copious quantities of cigarettes that soldiers smoke.

In 2004, the Department of Defense asked Dr. Robert Miller of Vanderbilt University to examine a large cohort of soldiers who had come back from Iraq with unexplained shortness of breath. “Soldier after soldier going from elite athlete to someone who could not complete a two-mile run,” Miller said. “This is not something you see in a normal young adult — period.” While their X-rays were often normal, Miller went further and performed surgical biopsies on about 60 veterans, taking tissue samples from their lungs. A majority showed evidence of constrictive bronchiolitis, an incurable disease characterized by tiny particles lodged in the airways. “There was particulate matter in all of the biopsies,” Miller said. “It’s clearly inhalational.” Most of the soldiers Miller treated were medically discharged and received disability benefits. But after he reported his findings, the Defense Department stopped sending him patients. “They felt we had stepped over the line by doing aggressive biopsies,” he said.

Trump Surprises Wilkie by Naming Him Veterans Affairs Secretary Nominee

  Trump Surprises Wilkie by Naming Him Veterans Affairs Secretary Nominee President Donald Trump surprised Robert Wilkie Friday by announcing he would nominate the acting secretary of Veterans Affairs to lead the agency. “I’ll be informing him in a little while — he doesn’t know this yet — that we’re going to be putting his name up for nomination to be secretary of the Veterans administration," Trump said at a White House event on prison reform.Turning toward Wilkie, who was in the audience, the president added, “I’m sorry that I ruined the surprise.

Without the proper research explicitly linking the burn pits to symptoms, veterans are going to have a hell of a time receiving compensation, much less an official mea culpa from the DoD. The out-of- court settlement was pathetic: A maximum of ,000 spread out over the course of 10 years

That’s not the case, however, as US District Court Judge Roger Titus has dismissed a lawsuit by veterans and family members related to the health problems, and even deaths, caused by the burn pits , saying there was no way to hold anyone accountable for it.

On May 8, a team of medical researchers published an article in the journal Experimental Lung Research in which they reported creating an animal model of burn-pit symptoms by injecting samples of dust collected from Iraq’s Camp Liberty base into the tracheas of mice. One of the authors, Dr. Anthony Szema, formerly the V.A.’s chief of allergy medicine, and now with Hofstra’s Zucker School of Medicine, said the carbonaceous and metallic particles that lodged in the air sacs of the mice were identical to those seen in Miller’s biopsies. “If you were in a burn pit, you definitely inhaled this stuff,” Szema said. “And it definitely causes lung injury.”

Lauren Price returned home from Iraq feeling sick and unable to explain why. Halfway through her 2007 deployment, she came down with the “creeping crud,” as she called the material in her lungs, and by 2008, “I couldn’t walk. I couldn’t climb stairs. The crap in my lungs kept getting worse, until it was hard to breathe.”

Doesn’t the V.A. compensate sick veterans?

The V.A. compensates veterans for injuries and disabilities incurred as a result of military service, including illnesses and disease. But when the onset of a chronic health condition is delayed, causation can be hard to prove.

The V.A.’s current position on burn pits is that there is not enough evidence to prove a direct connection between exposure and the many health issues veterans are reporting. A 2011 government-funded assessment of existing research said there may be long-term health effects, but the evidence was lacking and the data inconclusive. The V.A. may grant disability benefits for various pulmonary ailments, including asthma, but only if the veteran proves it resulted from military service.

Senate sends major VA reform bill to Trump's desk

  Senate sends major VA reform bill to Trump's desk The Senate easily cleared legislation on Wednesday overhauling medical care options for veterans, sending the bill to President Trump's desk.Senators voted 92-5 on the proposal, termed the VA Mission Act, with only a simple majority needed to pass the bill. Sens. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii), Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.), Mike Rounds ( R-S.D.) and Bob Corker (R-Tenn.) voted against the legislation.With its passage, the bill will meet Trump's public deadline and arrive on his desk before Congress departs for a week-long Memorial Day recess. The bill passed the House last week in a 347-70 vote.

The families of suffering and dying Iraqi veterans , who breathed in toxic fumes because of the negligence of military contractors, received some According to Hickman, the upper management of KBR said at one point, “If they ’re going to investigate us over these burn pits , don’t worry about it.

4. The burn pit registry is a helpful tool for Veterans and Researchers. The VA needs to rethink who was exposed to these hazards as far back as the can. We sent over 25000 service men and women to that country and burn pits was the only way to get rid of trash and feces.

“The V.A. says ‘Prove it,’” said Greg Lovett, who made “Delay, Deny, Hope You Die,” a documentary about veterans with burn-pit symptoms trying to get benefits. “How can you prove it? You’re sick, and you’re trying to take care of yourself, you’ve got all these medical bills, you’re not getting the medicine you need, appointments are getting postponed, cancelled, and the burden is on you to show this is service-related.”

What does KBR have to do with it?

The engineering and construction firm KBR, which made more money off the Iraq war than any other corporation, provided a wide range of logistical services to the armed forces in Iraq and in Afghanistan, which included the day-to-day operation of 119 burn pits.

Denied benefits by the V.A., many veterans went after KBR directly, filing some 63 lawsuits, including 44 class-action suits, claiming negligence and other causes of action. In 2008, the lawsuits, spread across 43 states, were consolidated into a single proceeding, Metzgar v. KBR Inc. The multidistrict litigation involves hundreds of plaintiffs, millions of pages of documents and dozens of depositions, but after 10 years it is still far from the trial phase, stalled out over the technical jurisdictional arguments that KBR’s lawyers have advanced. All the litigation to date has dealt with the preliminary question of whether KBR can even be sued.

In January 2018, the judge of a workers’ compensation case in the Department of Labor decided that burn-pit exposure was to blame for a KBR contractor’s pulmonary condition. It was the first instance of a federal agency accepting the premise, but it was an administrative-law decision, not binding on other agencies or the courts.

Palin's son seeks to bar media in assault proceedings

  Palin's son seeks to bar media in assault proceedings The eldest son of former Republican vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin is seeking to bar the media from covering court hearings after he was accused of assaulting his father last year. A lawyer for 29-year-old Track Palin filed a motion Friday to prohibit or limit media access to proceedings in Veterans Court. The motion says they want to ensure that the case does not become a distraction to other veterans in the system. Veterans Court is part of Alaska therapeutic court system.Load Error

As early as 2004, veterans who had served near burn pits began complaining of a complex and The issue of multifactorial exposure is at the heart of the battle over burn - pit disabilities. “You have a concern about people coming back , people getting ill, and then do you go do a study by comparing

The long, sad story of burn pits has included years of US veterans facing major health ramifications from being stationed near the pits , breathing in the toxic fumes from them . This is likely not over . Judge Titus tried to summarily dismiss this same case back in 2013, with the exact same argument

Why was the lawsuit dismissed?

In July 2017, the trial court judge, Robert W. Titus of the District of Maryland, held that it was the military’s decision to dispose of solid waste in burn pits, not KBR’s, and that federal courts have no power to second-guess the executive branch’s wartime decisions, a precedent known as the political-question doctrine. He also held that “sovereign immunity,” which generally shields the federal government from being sued, extends to private contractors supporting the military in a combat zone.

The plaintiffs appealed to the Fourth Circuit, saying that Judge Titus got it wrong.

“We needn’t second-guess any military decision,” Susan L. Burke, lead counsel for the veterans, told the panel of appellate judges. She said the evidence shows that most of KBR’s burn pits were in fact unauthorized.

Warren W. Harris, who argued the case for KBR, ridiculed that notion. “Burn pits were being operated in plain view of thousands of soldiers across two theaters of war,” he said, meaning the military must have known and approved of what KBR was doing.

Even assuming that’s true, Burke said, KBR violated its contract with the military by burning hazardous waste.

There is little evidence of that, Harris responded.

Price told The Times that she personally burned hazardous waste on instructions from KBR personnel, including auto parts, batteries, mattresses, styrofoam and computers. “The KBR guy sitting in an air-conditioned office would come out and take one look in the truck and say ‘Dump it right there,’” she said. “For them to deny it now is insulting.”

Aside from these questions of fact, the extent to which private military contractors like KBR share the government’s immunity from being sued is an unsettled area of U.S. law.

“It’s incoherent,” said Stephen Vladeck, a professor at the University of Texas School of Law who writes for the blog Lawfare. Military contractors can be court-martialed or indicted in the United States for their actions overseas, he said, but judges are all over the map on the question of whether they can be held liable for negligence and other civil misconduct. If the Supreme Court doesn’t step in to “clean up the mess,” he said, Congress should pass a law making it clear one way or the other. “And if the contractors really aren’t going to be held liable,” he said, “by what mechanisms are they going to be held to account?”

Former President Bush attends Maine pancake breakfast

  Former President Bush attends Maine pancake breakfast KENNEBUNKPORT, Maine (AP) — Former President George H.W. Bush is getting out and meeting veterans in the Maine community where he spends the summers. On Saturday, the 93-year-old former president attended the monthly pancake breakfast at the American Legion Post 159 in Kennebunkport. In addition to local veterans, Bush was joined by former National Security Adviser Brent Scowcroft. Bush arrived in Kennebunkport last week, about a month after the death of his wife of 73 years, Barbara.Bush has spent part of every summer in Kennebunkport since childhood with the exception of during his service as a naval aviator during World War II.

KBR had argued that it couldn’t be sued because it had operated the burn pits for the government. The Court issued no statement, but the lawsuits will go back to trial courts . This brings me hope for all of our veterans —not just those involved in this case.

What happens if the veterans win?

If the case is reinstated, the plaintiff veterans will still have to litigate the complex medical question of causation. KBR denies that burn pits are harmful to human health. “Military personnel deployed to Southwest Asia were exposed to many hazardous conditions, including the harsh ambient air,” a representative of KBR wrote in an emailed statement. “The government’s best scientific and expert opinions have repeatedly concluded there is no link between any long-term health issues and burn-pit emissions.”

If the Court of Appeals upholds the dismissal, only the Supreme Court will have the power to reinstate the case.

“I don’t want to sugarcoat it,” Vladeck said. “The plaintiffs face an uphill battle.”

Is Congress doing anything about this?

After years of inaction, Congress has shown some inclination to intervene. In 2010, lawmakers banned the military from using burn pits except where there was no feasible alternative. In 2013, Congress mandated the creation of the V.A. registry, and the 2018 defense-spending bill required the V.A. to coordinate further research on the effects of burn pits. On May 1, members of the House of Representatives announced the creation of a bipartisan congressional caucus on burn pits, and a hearing on veterans’ health issues is scheduled for June.

Congress has the power to direct the V.A. to presumptively grant disability benefits to veterans with lung disease if they were exposed to burn pits, but so far no member of Congress has proposed a bill to do so.

The Veterans of Foreign Wars is trying to change that. “For every generation’s war, there is some toxic exposure,” said Kenneth Wiseman, the V.F.W.’s associate legislative director. “In Vietnam it was Agent Orange. Then gulf war syndrome. Now burn pits.” He said the V.F.W. is currently lobbying Congress to direct the V.A. to create a list of illnesses presumed to be caused by burn-pit exposure. The V.A. would grant disability benefits to any Iraq or Afghanistan veteran with a listed condition, so that “individuals don’t have to assemble mountains of evidence one by one.”

That is what Congress did for Vietnam veterans exposed to Agent Orange, but not until 1991 — 16 years after the Vietnam War ended, 22 years after a National Cancer Institute study demonstrated a link between Agent Orange and cancer in mice and 25 years after the scientist who helped invent the defoliant first sounded the alarm over its potential harmfulness to humans.

Sign up for our newsletter to get the best of The New York Times Magazine delivered to your inbox every week. For more coverage of conflict, visit nytimes.com/atwar.

Former President Bush attends Maine pancake breakfast .
KENNEBUNKPORT, Maine (AP) — Former President George H.W. Bush is getting out and meeting veterans in the Maine community where he spends the summers. On Saturday, the 93-year-old former president attended the monthly pancake breakfast at the American Legion Post 159 in Kennebunkport. In addition to local veterans, Bush was joined by former National Security Adviser Brent Scowcroft. Bush arrived in Kennebunkport last week, about a month after the death of his wife of 73 years, Barbara.Bush has spent part of every summer in Kennebunkport since childhood with the exception of during his service as a naval aviator during World War II.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!