Crime Court Orders New Murder Trial for Man Who Claimed Wife Died by Suicide

09:00  12 february  2018
09:00  12 february  2018 Source:   lawandcrime.com

Agency: Nevada inmate serving 2 life terms dead at age 83

  Agency: Nevada inmate serving 2 life terms dead at age 83 An 83-year-old Nevada prison inmate serving two life terms, including one for killing a fellow prisoner, has died three decades after his case resulted in a U.S. Supreme Court decision that spared him the death penalty. Raymond Wallace Shuman died at Carson Tahoe Medical Center in Carson City on Friday, nearly 60 years after he was committed to his first sentence for murder in Nevada's Mineral County in 1958.The state Department of Corrections did not release a cause of death, but said he previously had been housed at the Northern Nevada Correctional Center in Carson City before being admitted to the hospital.

Steven Jones Murder Trial . Shadivia Phillips Hearing for Viral Brawl. View All Past Trials . High Profile. He is getting a new chance to argue his wife died by suicide because justices ruled that the conviction in part stood on unreliable expert testimony.

Komasquin Lopez is serving a 16-to-life sentence for the murder of wife Shannon Lopez, but that might change after the Utah Supreme Court ordered a new trial in his case. He is getting a new chance to argue his wife died by suicide because justices ruled that the conviction in part stood on unreliable

a close up of a person © Provided by LawNewz, Inc.

Komasquin Lopez is serving a 16-to-life sentence for the murder of wife Shannon Lopez, but that might change after the Utah Supreme Court ordered a new trial in his case. He is getting a new chance to argue his wife died by suicide because justices ruled that the conviction in part stood on unreliable expert testimony. The Court also found that the trial court erred in allowing evidence of prior bad acts including that Lopez allegedly pointed a gun at Shannon Lopez in previous incident, and also at his ex-wife in separate incidents.

Here’s the defense side of the case, as explained in the ruling. The defendant testified that he and his wife got into an argument December 2013 after he picked her up from work. The fight was over her meth use. (She had taken a “toxic” amount of the drug, according to medical examiners.) Lopez said they each said they were going to leave the other. Shannon reportedly said she was going to take the kids and go to her dad’s. Lopez testified he heard a sound like glass breaking, and turned to see Shannon “slumped forward.”

Suspect in Paris attacks refuses to cooperate in court

  Suspect in Paris attacks refuses to cooperate in court The only known surviving suspect in the 2015 Paris terror attacks appeared in court in Brussels Monday, but refused to cooperate or answer questions. It was the first public appearance for 28-year-old Salah Abdeslam since his arrest in Belgium in March 2016, according to Reuters news agency. He is on trial for charges related to a gunfight with authorities that preceded his arrest.Abdeslam is accused of attempted murder in a terrorist context and illegal possession of firearms, charges which carry up to 20 years in prison if convicted. The prosecutor is calling for the maximum sentence.

Komasquin Lopez is serving a 16-to-life sentence for the murder of wife Shannon Lopez, but that might change after the Utah Supreme Court ordered a new trial in his case. He is getting a new chance to argue his wife died by suicide because justices ruled that the conviction in part stood on unreliable

19 to report that his wife , Virginia, 69, who had been terminally ill with breast and liver cancer, had just died in their room at the Comfort Inn in A version of this article appears in print on September 8, 1990, on Page 1001010 of the National edition with the headline: Murder Trial Is Ordered for Man

He crashed the car on the way to the hospital. Cops found a gun and holster in the driver’s side of the vehicle, and determined that the victim was shot in the left ear. Whoever fired the bullet fired intentionally, investigators said.

The defense brought evidence of Shannon Lopez’s history of contemplating suicide. She had previously sent her husband a text message saying she wanted to die; discussed suicide with her son; and a month before her death, threatened to shoot and kill herself.

To fight this, prosecutors brought up expert testimony from clinical psychologist Dr. Craig Bryan, who used a “Fluid Vulnerability Theory of Suicide (FVTS)” to show Shannon Lopez didn’t die by suicide.

“This baseline risk can be ‘offset[]’ by ‘protective factors,’ such as an optimistic outlook, a strong support network, or motherhood,” the ruling said, quoting and paraphrasing the doctor. “‘Acute risk,’ on the other hand, ‘entails the emotional, physiological, behavioral, and cognitive factors associated with an active suicidal episode.’ Taking baseline and acute risk together, the model posits that ‘a triggering event will only lead to suicide among individuals with sufficient [baseline risk].'”

Attorneys say evidence tampering in James Jordan murder

  Attorneys say evidence tampering in James Jordan murder FAYETTEVILLE, N.C. — The killer serving life in prison for murdering NBA legend Michael Jordan's father has seen his bid for a new trial postponed for months after a new state law forced off the judge weighing his request. The Fayetteville Observer reports the law affects Daniel Andre Green, who with an accomplice killed James Jordan along a North Carolina road. His body was dumped in a South Carolina swamp.The law stops retired judges who return to the bench to fill judicial gaps from taking lengthy cases unless they involve business disputes.

Braulio Castillo appealed, and Circuit Court Judge Stephen E. Sincavage, now presiding over the murder trial Rueda said it did show Braulio Castillo. “That man entered his wife ’s home,” Rueda said. Then he took her into the downstairs basement, strung her up and made it look like a suicide .

Midvale man claimed he was innocent at trial , said wife died of suicide . Man murdered wife as they drove in vehicle, jury determines. Prison sentence ordered for man who murdered wife while driving.

Basically, the argument is that all the available elements together showed that Shannon Lopez didn’t die by suicide. Lopez’s defense said that she really took her own life. Their expert witness called it a “classic suicide.”

Justices ruled that the prosecution’s testimony shouldn’t have been admitted under the Utah Rule of Evidence 702.

“Dr. Bryan provided no information on how effective the theory was at determining suicide risk of those who are deceased, nor did he indicate whether there was any peer-reviewed literature regarding this application,” he wrote. “Indeed, it appears that Dr. Bryan never even addressed whether FVTS had ever been used to assess the risk of someone who had died.”

Then there’s the matter of prior acts by Lopez. He allegedly 1) pointed a gun at Shannon’s head; 2) hit his ex-wife in the stomach, pointed a gun at her head, and threatened to kill them both if she ever tried to divorce him; and 3) “pointed a gun at her head while she was in a closet.”

In the first instance, justices ruled that it wasn’t similar to the crime: The couple was demonstrating for a coworker how to effectively kill someone, so Lopez pointed the firearm near Shannon’s left ear. In the second and third instances, the justices stated it could not be relied for accuracy.

“The two incidents where Lopez threatened his ex-wife with a gun are the most similar to one another but because his ex-wife ‘could not recall the [closet] incident with great detail[,]’ the district court may not have been well-positioned to accurately assess the degree of similarity of those events,” the ruling stated.

[Mugshot via Salt Lake County]

Teen Accused of Aiding Utah Girl's Suicide Can Stand Trial: '[It's] Like Getting Away With Murder' .
A Utah man who allegedly helped a 16-year-old girl hang herself and then filmed the suicide was found mentally competent to stand trial on a murder charge, PEOPLE confirms. Judge James Brady made the ruling in the Fourth District Court in Provo on Tuesday in the case of 18-year-old Tyerell Przybycien. Przybycien was also found competent to stand trial on the misdemeanor charge of failure to report the finding of a dead human body. The judge’s decision came after defense attorneys asked for a mental evaluation to be conducted on Przybycien. Geoffrey Fattah, a spokesperson with Utah State Courts, tells PEOPLE that Przybycien underwent two competency evaluations. Prosecutors allege that Przybycien purchased the rope used in the suicide and tied the noose for Jchandra Brown, who hanged herself in May 2017. Prosecutors also allege that Przybycien was fascinated with death and excited about aiding in the girl’s suicide, allegedly sending a text to a friend, exclaiming: “[It’s] like getting away with murder!” Defense attorneys do not dispute that Przybycien assisted in the suicide, but they have argued that the suicide note she left behind showed her suicide was her own decision. Brown’s body was found by local turkey hunters on May 6. She was hanging by a noose from a rope tied to a tree in Payson Canyon.

Source: http://us.pressfrom.com/news/crime/-119529-court-orders-new-murder-trial-for-man-who-claimed-wife-died-by-suicide/

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!